Wednesday, August 24, 2011

Whom would you say...

...is the greatest musician of all time? Bach?

Elvis?

Waka Flocka Flame?

Anthony Tommasini, writing in the Times today, makes the case for Franz Liszt (my emphasis):

In January, during my Top 10 Composers project, a two-week series of deliberative articles, blog posts and videos to come up with a list of the greatest composers in history, Liszt was never really a contender. Among comments from readers, there were surprisingly few calls to include him in this select group.

But if this exercise, an intellectual game played seriously, had involved coming up with the Top 10 musicians in history — those creative artists whose overall contributions had enormous influence on the art form — Liszt would easily have made the list. In fact, Liszt, born 200 years ago this Oct. 22, might have been my choice for the top spot.

One person who would agree is the musicologist Alan Walker. In his monumental three-volume Liszt biography and in two supplemental books, Mr. Walker makes a case for Liszt, who died in 1886, as the towering musical figure of the 19th century.

Three volumes and two supplemental books on Liszt? That may be a little more than I want to read. How about a blog post instead?

No comments: